Email marketing rules for solo builders: what US and UK regulators say

Published 2026-11-16.

You want to collect email addresses so you can reach people again, or you plan to email a few people directly about your product. Both count as email marketing, and regulators have written rules for it.

This guide sticks to what two regulators’ own pages say: the US Federal Trade Commission (FTC) and the UK Information Commissioner’s Office (ICO). It covers the US and the UK only. Where something is our own judgment, we say so. This is not legal advice.

The short version

  • In the US, the FTC’s guide covers any commercial email, including business-to-business email. It lists what every message must contain and how you must handle unsubscribes.
  • In the UK, marketing email to individuals generally needs their consent first, with a narrow exception called the soft opt-in. Marketing email to companies is treated differently.
  • Both regulators say that using someone else to send your email does not remove your own responsibility.

What the FTC says (US)

The FTC’s CAN-SPAM guide for business says the law is not only about bulk email. It covers any message whose main purpose is to advertise or promote a commercial product or service, and it makes no exception for business-to-business email. According to the guide, each message must:

  • Have accurate sender and routing information (From, To, Reply-To) and a subject line that matches what is inside.
  • Say clearly that it is an advertisement.
  • Include a valid physical postal address. The guide accepts a street address, a post office box registered with the US Postal Service, or a private mailbox registered with a commercial mail receiving agency.
  • Explain clearly how to opt out of future marketing email, in a way an ordinary person can recognize and understand.

When someone opts out, the guide says:

  • Your opt-out method must keep working for at least 30 days after you send the message.
  • You must honor the request within 10 business days. You can’t charge a fee or ask for more than an email address.
  • You can’t sell or transfer the address afterwards. The only exception is a company you hired to help you comply.

The FTC also says that hiring another company to handle your email marketing does not move your legal responsibility to them. The company whose product is promoted and the company that sends the message can both be held responsible. Penalties apply per email. The FTC page states a dollar figure that is adjusted for inflation, so we leave it out.

Our reading: the FTC’s list covers what each message must contain and how you treat opt-outs. It does not list getting someone’s permission before the first email. We took this from the page’s list and did not check other US laws.

What the ICO says (UK)

The ICO’s guidance on the Privacy and Electronic Communications Regulations (PECR) applies to anyone who sends, or instigates the sending of, direct marketing by email. Which rules apply depends on who receives it:

  • Unsolicited marketing to individuals needs their consent, or you must meet all the requirements of a soft opt-in. The ICO says individuals include sole traders and ordinary partnerships.
  • Unsolicited marketing to corporate subscribers does not need consent or a soft opt-in.
  • For both kinds of recipient, you must not disguise your identity, and you must give a valid contact address so people can opt out.

On consent, the ICO says it must be freely given, specific, informed and unambiguous, and people must take a positive action. In practice that means:

  • No pre-ticked boxes, and silence or inactivity does not count.
  • The request must name you and clearly cover marketing emails, not just “direct marketing” in general.
  • Consent should not be bundled into terms and conditions or made a condition of buying.
  • You should keep a record of who agreed, when and how, and it must be easy to withdraw consent.

The soft opt-in for products and services lets you email people without consent, but only if all five conditions are met. You collected their contact details directly from them. You did so while selling, or negotiating to sell, a product or service (the ICO says signing up for a free trial or asking for a quote can count, and browsing a website does not). You only market your own similar products or services. You offered a simple opt-out when you collected the details. And every later message offers an opt-out.

On lists, the ICO says a bought-in list is only usable if the people on it gave valid consent that names your organisation, and that no third-party list is “soft opt-in compliant”. Contact details that are publicly available are not consent. The ICO also says that using a bulk-email platform does not normally make that platform responsible, so you stay responsible.

Where the two differ

  • Starting point: the FTC’s list is about message contents and opt-outs. The ICO makes consent, or the soft opt-in, the starting point for individuals.
  • Business recipients: the FTC makes no exception for business email. The ICO allows unsolicited marketing to corporate subscribers without consent, but its own page counts sole traders and ordinary partnerships as individuals.
  • Consent boxes: the ICO says no pre-ticked boxes. The FTC page we read does not discuss consent boxes.

They agree on two things: unsubscribing must be easy, and using someone else to send does not remove your responsibility.

What this means for you

This section is our own judgment, not a legal conclusion.

  • If you collect addresses on your site, one approach that fits both regulators is a form that says what emails people will get from you, with nothing pre-ticked, and only adding people who sign up themselves.
  • Put an unsubscribe link and a postal address in every marketing email. If you don’t want to publish a home address, the FTC page lists a registered post office box or a registered private mailbox as options. That is a US rule. We did not check what UK rules require for the address.
  • Keep a simple record of who signed up, when and how. The ICO says you should.
  • Don’t build a list from purchased lists or from contact details you found on public pages. The ICO says neither counts as consent.
  • Before cold emailing a solo builder, don’t assume a one-person business counts as a company. The ICO page puts sole traders with individuals, and from the outside you usually can’t tell how someone trades.
  • Process unsubscribes automatically and right away. The FTC allows up to 10 business days, but doing it immediately is simpler to get right.

A small first step

Open your signup form and your email template and check four things. Does the form say what emails people will get from you? Is any consent box pre-ticked? Does the template have an unsubscribe link and a postal address? Can you tell when and how each person signed up? Fixing whichever answer is “no” is a good first step before you send anything. This list is our own suggestion.

What we could not verify

  • Rules outside the US and the UK, including EU countries, Canada and others. We did not read them.
  • US rules beyond CAN-SPAM, including state laws.
  • How the ICO decides who counts as a corporate subscriber. Its separate pages on business-to-business marketing were not read, so we can’t say how to classify a particular contact.
  • Whether a newsletter signup can rely on the soft opt-in. The ICO page does not discuss newsletter signups specifically, and we make no claim either way.
  • Current penalty amounts. We left the FTC’s figure out because it is adjusted every year.
  • Both pages are regulator guidance and can change. This guide is not legal advice.

Sources

Last checked 2026-11-16.

Related guide: How to take part in Reddit communities without it counting as spam.

Free tool for this: Launch Channel Picker: Where to Find Your First Users